Embedded Files
Push your luck is one of the best board game mechanics - and the moment my playtesters started cheering for the player trying to beat them, I understood why.
During a game of Station Decimus, one player had fallen behind quite far. In the last mission, everyone else had returned to safety and were counting their points. This player, however, decided to push their luck that bit further. They kept going, kept racking up loot, and slowly climbed from last place toward the winner. Then they pushed further still. Everyone around the table was watching, willing them on, waiting to see if the next card would finish them off or if they'd survive another round. They survived. Again and again, until they'd exhausted every safe option in the deck and returned with a sweeping victory. The other players erupted.
That's why, if done right, push your luck is one of the best board game mechanics there is. I'll look at what makes it work, what ruins it, and the games that get it right. If you'd prefer to watch, the video below covers the same ground.
What Is Push Your Luck?
Push your luck is the mechanic, or category of mechanics, where you decide: do you go that bit further, or do you stick with what you've got? Roll another dice, reveal another card, or bank your points and walk away. The further you go, the bigger the rewards - but the higher the chance you lose everything you've built so far. It sounds simple but has the ability to create some of the most memorable moments you'll find around a gaming table.
What Makes Push Your Luck Work?
I think there are two things push your luck does better than almost any other mechanic.
The first is that it can unify a whole table behind one player, even in a competitive game. Everyone can see the odds and know how slim the chances are but egg another player on to go further. When that player beats the odds, the table can erupt - the fact the other players have just lost seems irrelevant compared to the fact that the other player won.
The second is the anticipation. There's a pause between the decision to push your luck and finding out whether it was the right one. That moment - when you've committed but don't know the outcome yet - is one of the best feelings in board games. A bad outcome doesn't ruin it, you still get the anticipation, that feeling just before the reveal is great regardless of what comes next. Push your luck is one of the few mechanics where losing can still feel like a win.
What Ruins Push Your Luck?
Not all push your luck games get this right. My first experience of the mechanic was Deep Sea Adventure by Oink Games, and I loved it... at first. There was tension, tough choices and I was completely sold on push your luck board games.
But the more I played it, the more I noticed how often I wasn't able to push my luck because the choices were so heavily influenced by other players' decisions. Sometimes the choice was practically made for me. With push your luck, when the decision isn't really yours, the mechanic stops working. A player should be able to lose and look back and think "I should've stopped earlier" Not "what other choice did I have?".
Deep Sea Adventure also has a relatively small decision space. Once you understand the core loop, there isn't a lot of variation in what you can do. That can leave you feeling like the game is happening to you rather than you playing the game. It's still enjoyable, but it doesn't create those memorable moments. Autonomy is everything. If the player owns the decision, they own the outcome - good or bad.
The Best Push Your Luck Board Games
Spots is a great example of push your luck done well. You're rolling dice and placing them on your very cute Dalmatian cards, trying to match the spots without busting. The decisions are entirely yours - which trick to take, how many dice to roll, when to cut your losses.
What Spots does particularly well is layer push your luck on top of itself. When you complete a dog card it stays face up until you choose to score it, which takes a whole turn. Or you can try a trick that scores all your face-up cards at once - high risk, high reward. This leads to genuine Hail Mary moments where a player rolls eight dice needing eight exact numbers to win. Sometimes they pull it off. Everyone cheers, even the players they've just beaten.
Quacks of Quedlinburg needs a mention - it uses bag building, where you're drawing chips from a bag to make potions. The wrong chips though and your potion explodes and you're out the round. The tactile element here is really satisfying. Reaching into a bag and not knowing what's coming adds a physical dimension to the tension. The components are doing real work.
A Great Family Friendly Board Game Mechanic
Something I hadn't thought about until a friend pointed it out is that push your luck can be a genuine playing field leveller for younger players.
A small child playing a deeply tactical game against an experienced adult is probably going to lose almost every time. But push your luck changes that equation. Children have very different risk appetites to adults; they'll take the action a grown-up would never take, pull the one-in-a-hundred card, and suddenly find themselves winning. I've seen it happen in Station Decimus. Everyone retreated because the odds look so slim, one young player kept exploring, gathered more loot, and beat every adult there. They might not win often but they have a chance which can often make push your luck games great family board games.
What Push Your Luck Tells You About the People You Play With
I'm a people person, and one of the things I find genuinely interesting about push your luck games is what they reveal about the players around the table. Risk appetite varies enormously between people, and I love seeing how it plays out. Who pushes further than you'd expect? Who retreats earlier than they should? Sometimes it's very different to what you'd predict. It's one of the small pleasures of a good push your luck game.
How It Inspired Station Decimus
The core gameplay loop at the heart of Station Decimus came from Diamant (or Incan Gold). I'd heard about it from one of Jamie Stegmaier's videos - the idea of flipping cards until you hit two of the same bad one, at which point you lose. It stuck with me. The visible build-up of odds, the shared odds and the decision to keep going or get out, became the core loop of Station Decimus.
From a board game design perspective I've tried to build on that and make every other decision in the game another form of risk versus reward. The initiative order is a simple choice: do you go at the front where the loot is most valuable, or the back where you're safer? The action cards: do you play them now or bank them for points later?
Station Decimus also plays across four missions, which means dying doesn't end your game. It just changes your risk appetite for the next mission. A player who's fallen behind is suddenly more willing to take chances. A player in the lead is much more cautious. That dynamic means the last mission is always interesting.
A BGG reviewer recently described it as "Diamant on steroids". Which is exactly what I was going for. If you want to see if you agree, you can grab a free Print and Play by signing up below.
How to Stop Push Your Luck Games Feeling Unfair
One of the complaints sometimes levelled at push your luck games is that they can feel unfair. Random outcomes mean sometimes you will get unlucky through no fault of your own. In Station Decimus the encounter deck is shared meaning everyone faces the same odds. It doesn't eliminate bad luck, but at least the bad luck is the same for everyone.
At Handycon, I had a group hit the alien card - the only unsurvivable encounter in the game - in round one. Then they hit it again in round two, triggering it and wiping out everyone. The whole table burst out laughing. Everyone was certain the odds of it happening twice were too slim to worry about. They kept exploring. They were wrong.
Even better was the session where the first mission started with double aliens. Like the earlier story everyone was wiped out. When the second mission started and the first card was an alien everyone was already laughing. Everyone was very certain the odds of it happening again were so small they continued. Only to be wiped out again. The odds were slim, but it happened. Everyone loved it.
These moments have come up in blind playtesting feedback too - people specifically calling out the double alien as a highlight of their session. Bad luck that could feel frustrating instead becomes a shared moment that everyone around the table is part of. That's one of the best things about push your luck - when it works, even the worst outcome is a good story.
If you enjoyed this and are interested in other board game mechanics, I've written about ticking clocks and quarterbacking in previous pieces - both look at how design decisions shape the experience at the table.
Google Sites
Report abuse